File talk:Wikiversity Problem 2.2.3.pdf

Katelin, I think you have done a wonderful job. Your uploaded file is both effective and creative. Your explanation is broke down enough for anyone to understand without prior knowledge of if then statements. It is hard to find something for you to edit or change. Great job.

Jamie Balayti

I think your charts and explanation were very clear and explained the problem very well. You went into great detail, which would be very beneficial to people who have never been exposed to truth-tables before. If I wasn't in this class and had never seen a truth-table before, I think I would have understood this problem from reading your work on how you got to your conclusion. Good job! -Katy Anderson

I agree with the other two critiques that this diagram and explanation are very clear-cut and and excellent way for someone who has difficulties with if-then charts to have the basics laid out explicitly. The only specific line that could use a little more explanation is the if F then T statement where it was mentioned that If you do not stop then the light is red. That one could be confusing to a reader. But really, that this was excellent and you should have written this section for the course reader.

Rehus1 01:53, 3 November 2010 (UTC)