User:Sylvain Ribault/Peer review

This page is for notes on doing peer review and/or journal clubs at Wikiversity. The idea is to create a page for one (or several) academic article or preprint. The page should have some structure, in particular it may give ratings. Also, it should unambiguously identify the article by its DOI or Arxiv number, and this should probably not be relegated to a reference. Ideally, we could have an infobox which would nicely display all the bibliographical information.

Ratings template
Rating an article means choosing one of a few possible ratings in a few rating areas. This is analogous to the conservation status in the template w:Template:Speciesbox, see Black rhinoceros for an example. (The conservation status according to two different organizations is analogous to ratings in two areas.) The template calls w:Template:Taxobox/core (which formats the display as a box) which itself calls w:Template:Taxobox/species which itself calls image files such as. For formatting, see also Template:Peer-review infobox.

Example of a rating image:

Template syntax: see here.