User talk:Stress9/HW5

Templates: $$\displaystyle \clubsuit$$ Copyright violation / plagiarism: Completeness: Team contribution: Correctness: Artistic aspect: Comments: Overall rating:

 Note: The Overall rating: here is more of a "gut feeling" than a formal quantitative grading. Follow our list of criteria for formal grading and commenting. In case of a tie, let's favor new teams for the top-3 positions. Specific comments are given for a few teams, with a focus on the top teams to serve as a standard that other teams are measured against. The best of HW5 wiki page for each course is the grading standard; I also add some annotations in the HW reports that I looked through so to warn you of errors, incompleteness, etc. As you grade and see the best features in the HW reports, do not hesitate to add the teams with these best features to this wiki page. FEAD: Ready for grading. AERO: Ready for grading. Eml4500.f08 12:10, 14 November 2008 (UTC)

=EML 4500=

User:Eml4500.f08/HW_report_table

General comments for HW5

 * The The best of HW5 is the grading standard, which is also accessible at the bottom of the HW report table.


 * classnotes 60% + matlab problem 40% = 100%


 * contributing team members: I noticed that not all team members contributed to the HW reports; see e.g., Team Aero6 HW4. Non-contributing team members get zero HW grade. Please revisit HW1, HW2, HW3, HW4 to check on contributing team members; non-contributing team members should get zero HW grade.

Specific comments on team HW5 reports
=EAS 4200C=

User:eas4200c.f08/HW_report_table

General comments for HW5

 * The The best of HW5 is the grading standard, which is also accessible at the bottom of the HW report table.


 * classnotes 50% + matlab problem 50% = 100%


 * contributing team members: I noticed that not all team members contributed to the HW reports; see e.g., Team Aero6 HW4. Non-contributing team members get zero HW grade. Please revisit HW1, HW2, HW3, HW4 to check on contributing team members; non-contributing team members should get zero HW grade.